“We are the only organism that is linear – we take, make and throw away. The rest of planet earth is an ecosystem where waste from one is food for another – there is no such thing as waste.”
In the context of creating buildings, circularity should mimic this ecosystem by eliminating the concept of waste. The Greenwich Millennium Village project is an example of how this could work. The project that Baker Brown was involved with at the design stage was planned with circular aspirations in mind – where buildings were designed not as permanent monoliths, but as building materials stores that can be dismantled for the future – buildings that are put together with their ultimate deconstruction being very much part of the design.
Baker Brown also pointed to the deconstruction of the World Trade Center in Brussels. Rather than following a traditional demolition process, the building is being carefully dismantled by Rota DC, a non-profit organisation that salvages materials and puts them back into the supply chain.
“In essence, the key to circularity is to avoid materials with no end-of-life strategy”. Baker Brown highlighted the challenge of replacing plastic insulation with organic options and mentioned an example at Glynebourne, where mycelium is the chosen insulation material and is actually grown on site. A more commonplace example might be the use of lime-based mortar rather than cement-based mortar in walls, allowing for bricks to be recycled more easily.
It is not impossible to achieve circularity; progress is certainly being made and Baker Brown referenced Amsterdam which already claims to have achieved 30% circularity. In the UK there are encouraging and exciting examples, with local authorities such as Brighton and Hove working on a road map to circularity. Such progress involves looking to reuse buildings that already exist and understanding how to source new, local, low-carbon materials for the future.
However, there is an important distinction to make, as circularity involves being able to reuse materials for their original purpose. Manufacturers can claim that their products are “recyclable” if the materials can be reused and made into something else. Recycling is the first step to circularity.
“We live here on planet earth, where temperatures have never been so high. We have a moral obligation in the construction industry to do something about this People are really starting to understand embodied carbon and architects are very well placed to understand how to deconstruct buildings from any era.”